Dude.
This is fucking sad as fuck. Maybe it wasn't the best quality, or the singing that great....but it just made me think of some poor fucker, no job, no money, no family, no hope. Sitting in his box, listening to this scratched up record on an old phonograph. Doesn't even really know what the song is anymore...but never even cared.
In essence, this is goddamn perfect. It made me fucking depressed...and not because of the "shittiness" as others have said....if you know what I mean.
I actually liked this version better than your other ones, cause it just had the vibe of depression and sadness. Truly man.
At 1:19 it kinda took away from the effect. If you faded out to there...or let it loop at 1:18, this would be the saddest fucking song ever.
I'm gonna go blow my brains out now.